|
Competitive
cyclists who have achieved maximal results from their training
programs often turn to extrinsic aids (termed ergogenic aids)
to enhance their performance.
These include mechanical aids (equipment), psychological
aids (hypnosis, psychotherapy), pharmacological aids (erythropoietin)
and nutritional aids (creatine phosphate, vitamins, minerals).
The
use of performance enhancing dietary supplements can be traced
back to the Romans who reportedly drank lion's blood to improve
their strength and courage. Today, unfortunately, nutritional
supplements are frequently promoted with unsubstantiated claims.
Based
on various reviews, those supplements that are clearly helpful
and beneficial for improving cycling performance are shown
with (++). The text will be clear for those that have nothing
other than anecdotal information to recommend them.
The
following are in alphabetical order.
ALCOHOL
Occasional
articles will appear touting the benefits of alcohol as an energy
source for sports activities. Although alcohol does contain more
energy per gram (7 Cal/gram) than carbohydrates, and is rapidly
absorbed from the intestinal tract, the available evidence suggests
these Calories are not utilized to any significant extent during
exercise. Thus its negative effects outweigh any theoretical positive
ones. These include:
it
is a diuretic and contributes to dehydration
it slows down glucose production and release from the liver
it disturbs motor skills including balance and coordination
In
a recent study 10 women were given a mixed drink equal to a moderate
drink. They then rode stationary bikes for 30 minutes at 70% of
their maximum heart rate. Compared to their own baseline performance
off alcohol, cycling after alcohol required more energy, produced
a higher heart rate, and stimulated a higher cardiovascular demand.
Even moderate drinking while exercising placed increased demands
on the cardiovascular system. The bottom line is therefore a definite
negative influence on performance, as if you didn’t know..
ASTRAGALUS
A root herb from the Mongolian wilderness. Reported to increase
the body's capacity to handle stress, and help reduce fatigue
and enhance endurance. There are no studies with specifics. aAll
information is purely anecdotal.
BORON
Boron has been reported to increase serum testosterone levels
and subsequently the lean body mass and strength of male athletes.
However, a carefully controlled study of 19 male body builders,
half of whom received 2.5 mg of boron per day for 7 weeks, demonstrated
no significant difference in total testosterone, lean body mass,
or strength. A normal diet will provide 10 mg/day of boron; 50
mg per day appears to be a toxic level.
CAFFEINE (++)
Caffeine is a member of a group of compounds called methylxanthines
found naturally in coffee beans, tea leaves, chocolate, cocoa
beans, guarana, and cola (kola) nuts.
During prolonged exercise, the onset of fatigue correlates
closely with the depletion of muscle glycogen stores. The metabolism of free fatty acids (FFA) as an alternative
energy source can lead to decreased use of muscle glycogen. Caffeine
can increase blood FFAs, and it is felt that this is its major
method of action. In one study, caffeine produced a 50% increase
in FFA at 3 to 4 hours. This effect was seen after 300 mg of caffeine
(An average 6 ounce cup of brewed coffee contains 100 - 150 mg
of caffeine).
There is speculation that some of its benefits may
also be related to its central nervous system effect as a stimulant,
and a recent study has demonstrated a direct positive effect on
the muscle fibre itself with a reported 7% increase in power output
over a 6 second cycle exercise task.
In
one controlled study, subjects were able to perform for 90 minutes
to fatigue as compared to 75 minutes in controls (a 20% increase)
after the drinking the equivalent of 3 cups of coffee or 6 caffeinated
colas 1 hour before, even though values for heart rate and oxygen
uptake were similar in both groups. Another study, looking at
performance with acute altitude change (4300 meters), demonstrated
a 50% increase in performance with caffeine supplements.
A suggested dose of caffeine for the recreational rider is 5 mg
per kg of body weight if you are taking a tablet or 1.2 cups of
coffee per 100 pounds of body weight taken 1 hour before the ride
although some riders prefer smaller doses taken periodically throughout
the ride itself.
But
there are potential side effects. Caffeine can cause headaches,
insomnia, and nervous irritability. In addition it is a potent
diuretic and can lead to dehydration. However the biggest negative
is that in high concentrations it is considered a drug and is
therefore banned.
The
bottom line is that most endurance athletes consider caffeine
useful if used correctly. This includes a period of abstinence
for several weeks before the event as habitual use induces tolerance.
CALCIUM
Calcium metabolism in the athlete is still not completely understood.
The question of an increased calcium requirement is linked to
concerns about osteoporosis in women athletes who, because of
the intensity of their training, have become amenorrheic. The
hormonal changes that occur with amenorrhea (associated with intense
training programs) affect bone formation and are thought to be
one of the causes of osteoporosis. Recent evidence has suggested
that the positive effects of exercise on bone formation may counteract
and cancel out bone loss. At this time, there is no consensus
on the need for calcium supplements.
CHOLINE
An amine widely
distributed in food, as well as synthesized in the body, choline
has been postulated to increase the production of the neurotransmitter
acetylcholine and thus prevent fatigue in endurance events. Even
with increased blood levels (ingestion of choline bitartrate,
2.34 grams), two separate studies failed to demonstrate any significant
improvement in cycling times to exhaustion at 70% VO2max.
CHROMIUM PICOLINATE
A chemical
compound reported to potentiate the effect of insulin, and help
build muscle and dissolve fat. However, 8 different studies, using
up to 200 micrograms of chromium picolinate daily, have failed
to demonstrate any changes in body composition or strength
compared to control groups administered a placebo. Current information
indicates that daily intakes of up to 400 micrograms are not toxic.
CITRATE
(Sodium Citrate) (++)
Sodium citrate was evaluated in a 30 km high intensity time trial
event at a dose of 0.5 grams per kg body weight. Total power output,
but not peak power output, was greater in this treated group.
At 30 km, the riders using sodium citrate had an average 100 second
lead. The cyclists using the sodium citrate had a higher venous
blood pH throughout the ride, and it is presumed that this buffering
effect led to the improved performance (by optimising the pH within
the muscle cell and enhancing contractility).
Sodium citrate has also been shown to increase peak power over
a placebo control group during short, high intensity cycle ergometry
of 120 and 240 seconds duration. Again, this is thought to be
related to optimising the pH within the active muscle cell.
CIWUJIA (Endurox
tm)
Ciwujia is an herb derived from a root grown in the northeast
section of China and used in traditional Chinese medicine for
over 1700 years to treat fatigue and bolster the immune system.
It is commercially prepared and marketed under the trade name
Endurox, and is claimed to shift energy metabolism in the exercising
muscle from carbohydrate to fat, thus sparing carbohydrate and
slowing lactic acid build-up. There is also a decrease in heart
rate during moderate exercise.
CoQ10 (coenzyme
Q10; ubiquinone)
A lipid found in mitochondria, as well as an anti-oxidant. In
a recent review of research on this compound, supplementation
of 100-150 mg/day for 4 - 8 weeks elicited no enhancement on metabolic
responses to sub maximal or maximal exercise, VO2max or cycle
time to exhaustion.
COLA
NUT (see also
caffeine)
A natural source of caffeine.
CREATINE
An organic
compound which, when combined with phosphate, yields creatine
phosphate, an intermediary in the energy transfer pathway in the
muscle cell which resynthesises ATP. Creatine is available through
nutritional supply stores in the form of creatine monohydrate,
and will increase body weight (whether this is water retention
of true muscle mass is still unproven). It is claimed to improve
performance during maximal strength or power tests (weight lifting)
and in repetitive high intensity bouts with short recovery intervals
(short sprints of 5 to 15 second duration).
However, the literature is split evenly on the question
of benefits for the competitive cyclist, and there are some questions
as to whether long term use of high doses might affect the kidneys.
No short-term toxicity has been reported at doses of 20 to 30
grams per day.
This
compound may be effective in limited situations. It is doubtful
that it is of any benefit for sprints lasting more than 30 to
45 seconds. The study most like a real life cycling situation,
an 18-mile time trial that included 6-15 second sprints, demonstrated
no difference between riders receiving creatine or a placebo.
So if competitors using this supplement are beating you, it is
probably for other reasons.
CYTOCHROME
C
Cytochromes are iron containing cellular enzymes that facilitate
energy transfer. The only controlled study of this compound examined
the effects of a supplement containing 500 mg cytochrome C on
eleven trained triathletes. The performance test included a treadmill
for 90 minutes at 70% VO2 max. followed by cycling to exhaustion
again at 70% VO2 max. There was no significant improvement.
DHEA (dehydroepiandrosterone)
DHEA is a steroid, related to cortisone, produced by the adrenal
gland. Maximum production occurs during the third decade of life
and then gradually declines with aging. Studies to date on it's
"anti-aging" effects are only preliminary and have given
conflicting results. Doses of 25 to 100 mg per day have been given
for 6 months to subjects over 60 years of age with variable results
on muscle strength and lean body mass. It appeared that men had
more of a response than women. At this time there is absolutely
no evidence that physical performance is modified in young, healthy
individuals.
DHAP (dihydroxyacetone
pyruvate)
A metabolic by-product of glycolysis that includes di-hydroxyacetone
and pyruvate in a 3:1 ratio. Several studies have suggested that
100 grams per day of DHAP for 7 days increased arm ergometer endurance
at 60% VO2max and cycle ergometer endurance time at 70%VO2max.
These studies are yet to be confirmed in well-trained athletes.
EPHEDRA
A short acting stimulant found in the traditional Chinese herb
tea Ma Huang, ephedra mimics adrenaline. The synthetic version,
ephedrine, is found in asthma and nasal decongestant (pseudoephedrine)
products. It has been used in tandem with other natural caffeine
sources such as kola nut and guarana. In higher doses it can cause
tremors, rapid breathing, nervousness and insomnia - common side
effects of caffeine as well.
Although
it appears to be safe in small amounts (up to 50 mg of ephedrine
or 2 cups of Ma Huang tea per day), a tolerance will develop (i.e.
it becomes less effective as time passes), and the International
Olympic Committee bans its use in any amount. In fact the USOC
advises athletes to eliminate all herb based teas and diet supplements
for one week prior to a race (and urine testing) if they are unsure
whether they might contain ephedra. Likewise check on any decongestant
and asthma medications to see if they contain ephedrine.
ERYTHROPOIETIN
(EPO)
EPO is a hormone, produced by the kidney, which stimulates the
bone marrow to produce red blood cells. It is available in injectable
form and can be self administered to "hyper"stimulate
the bone marrow. The result is an abnormally high red blood count
that effectively creates the same physiologic conditions as blood
doping. Unfortunately, when administered in an unmonitored manner,
the haematocrit can increase above 60%, increasing blood viscosity
and predisposing to the formation of blood clots (also aggravated
by the dehydration which occurs in competitive cycling). This
clotting tendency is speculated to be the explanation for the
cases of "sudden death , which have been reported after
hard training or racing - most likely from a heart attack or a
pulmonary embolism.
EPO
is banned in sanctioned events. But as it is almost impossible
to monitor for an excess of a hormone that is naturally produced,
it is the haematocrit that is monitored, not the hormone itself.
Any cyclist with a haematocrit greater than 50% is not allowed
to compete, regardless of the mechanism of the increased haematocrit.
Unfortunately this is not as fair as a test for EPO, but health
concerns were felt to override those of fairness.
FERULIC
ACID
Ferulic acid is derived from the natural plant sterol, frac, and
has been claimed to assist the body in maintaining greater workloads.
However these performance claims are not supported by published
research studies.
FRUCTOSE
A 6 carbon carbohydrate derived from fruit often touted as superior
to glucose as an energy source for the endurance athlete. However,
there is little evidence that fructose alone has any advantages
over glucose and may in fact have less of a glycogen sparing effect.
There is some evidence that its benefits lie in a combination
fructose/glucose sports drink.
GLUCOSAMINE
SULFATE
An over the counter agent derived from shark cartilage, glucosamine
sulfate is helpful in decreasing the joint pain from degenerative
or wear and tear arthritis (osteoarthritis). There is no evidence
that it decreases the muscular pain associated with over training.
GLYCEROL (++)
A chemical
compound that together with fatty acids forms triglycerides (the
most plentiful lipid in the body and the major form of lipid stored
in fat cells), glycerol is a clear, syrupy, and extremely sweet
substance which also has water retaining effects when taken orally.
In 1987, it was shown that resting subjects drinking a glycerol
solution retained 50% more fluid than when drinking a similar
volume of water alone. This led to investigation of its ability
to help prevent dehydration under extreme conditions of exercise,
heat, and high humidity.
GUARANA
A South American
herb used as a natural source of caffeine. The caffeine effect
of one teaspoon (100 mg) of guarana is equivalent to one cup of
coffee.
HERB TEA
(see also Ma Huang)
The biggest shortcoming of herb teas is the inability to identify
the active ingredients, increasing the possibility of taking a
substance banned by the IOC.
Strength of these teas is directly related to the brewing
time, making calculation of a "safe" dose difficult
and increasing the chances of a toxic side effect.
HMB
(beta-hydroxy-beta-methylbutyrate)
This metabolite of the amino acid leucine was studied in a group
of serious weight lifters (1.5 hours a day, 3 days a week) on
their "normal" diet of 117 grams of protein per day
(twice the Recommended Daily Requirement) and a high protein diet
of 175 grams per day.
HMB (1.5 and 3.0 grams per day) decreased the products of muscle
breakdown (muscle damage) found in the urine during the training
period, and increased the amount of weight lifted in each week
of the study when compared to a control group not using the supplement.
There was a dose related effect, that is the 1.5 gram per day
dose of HMB was beneficial but greater improvement was noted on
3.0 grams perday. There was no benefit of a high protein diet
compared to a normal protein diet (117 grams per day) either in
the control (no HMB) or HMB groups. Lower body strength improved
more than upper. The average increase in overall (averaged) strength
compared to the control (no HMB) group at week 3 was 13% for the
1.5 gram per day HMB supplement and 18% for the 3.0 gram per day
HMB supplemented group. No adverse effects were noted during the
study period.
HMB
is of use in a program of regular resistance training and appears
to work by minimizing the muscle damage that normally occurs.
It's role in aerobic conditioning or cycling where strength is
less of a factor has not been studied.
HUMIC
ACID
Humic substances (including humic acid) are ubiquitous in the
environment and may constitute as much as 95% of the total dissolved
organic matter in aquatic systems Although they have been touted
as a health supplement, their use at this time should be considered
risky.
INOSINE
Inosine is
a nucleoside theorized to enhance oxygen delivery during exercise.
However, the only available study in 9 highly trained runners
after 6 grams per day for 2 days reported no significant benefit
either during submaximal running or peak oxygen uptake and performance
in a treadmill run to exhaustion.
IRON
Iron is important as a component of haemoglobin in red blood cells
that transports oxygen from the lungs to the muscle cells, and
iron deficiency can cause fatigue and weakness. Although some
riders use iron supplements to alleviate the beat feeling they
experience after a long ride, a balanced diet easily meets the
RDA for iron (10 mg for men and 15 mg for women). Four ounces
of red meat contains 8 - 10 mg. As excess iron can be toxic, any
questions of a deficiency state are best resolved with a screening
blood test before resorting to supplements - any self-prescribing
has definite risks.
Athletes
involved in contact sports (including runners) are more likely
to be iron deficient than cyclists, but even regular cyclists
have an additional need of around 18 mg of iron per month. As you might expect, iron deficiency is more of a problem in
women athletes because of monthly menstrual blood loss. If you
ride regularly, taking a multivitamin with iron will help to prevent
anaemia. An alternative is to eat extra portions of iron containing
foods (dark green vegetables, prune juice, figs, and raisins).
KOLA NUT
(see caffeine)
The caffeine effect of one teaspoon (100 mg) of kola nut is equivalent
to one cup of coffee.
L-CARNITINE
A nitrogenous
compound found mainly in meats (a non-vegetarian diet contains
100-300 mg per day), but also synthesized in the kidney and liver
from lysine and methionine. Theorised to enhance aerobic endurance
by increasing the oxidation of glucose, decreasing the accumulation
of lactic acid, and enhancing fatty acid metabolism by the cellular
mitochondria.
NIACIN
(NICOTINIC ACID, VITAMIN B3)
The concentration (and thus availability) of fatty acids in the
blood is believed to directly influence their uptake and oxidation
by skeletal muscle. The use of niacin as a vitamin supplement
results in a lowering of blood free fatty acids levels at rest
and a blunting of the rise in free fatty acid levels normally
associated with prolonged exercise. Theoretically this should
reduce the use of free fatty acids as an energy source for skeletal
muscle during exercise, and require a compensatory increase in
the amount of carbohydrate metabolised from muscle glycogen stores
or blood glucose supplies. And one might even expect a potential
decrease in TOTAL muscle energy output because of a decrease in
the total energy Calories available to the muscle cell (fatty
acids and glucose).
However, as measured in actual controlled studies, the effects
on performance have been inconsistent. One investigator reported
impaired "run to exhaustion" times with nicotinic acid
supplements while another reported no impairment in performance
in a 10 mile run. As to cycling performance, one study failed
to demonstrate a difference in "cycling time to exhaustion"
while another reported a decrease in physical work capacity to
exhaustion in a one legged cycling model.
These conflicting results suggest that any decrease in overall
performance is probably small, affecting at most only a minority
of elite cyclists. However, as with all medications, there is
the occasional individual with a particular sensitivity and exaggerated
response in which case this medication could have an adverse effect
on their personal performance.
ORYZANOL
A plant extract claimed to have anabolic effects, this is a ferulic
acid compound derived from rice bran oil. Recent studies have
indicated it may actually decrease testosterone production. Any
effect on performance is purely speculative.
PANGAMIC ACID
(VITAMIN B15, D15)
Touted by many athletes as a performance enhancer (increased aerobic
capacity, increased endurance, decreased blood lactate levels),
there is no evidence from controlled studies as to any benefits
in athletic performance. Concern has been expressed as to possible
harmful effects to humans, and the FDA in America has made it
illegal to sell this as a diet supplement or drug.
PHOSPHATE
A blood phosphate compound (2,3 diphosphoglycerate, DPG) binds
with haemoglobin to facilitate the release of oxygen at the level
of the muscle capillary. Thus oral phosphate, a building block
of DPG, has been investigated as a performance enhancer. However
results have been conflicting and although there is some suggestive
evidence, this compound should be considered as unproven as an
ergogenic aid at this time.
Usual doses are 3 to 4 grams of calcium or sodium phosphate for
3-6 days. Phosphate supplements may cause gastrointestinal distress
unless consumed with ample fluids or food, and chronic consumption
may interfere with calcium balance.
PYCNOGENOL
A procyanidin extracted from the tree bark of the pine, Pinus
maritima. It is a free radical scavenger and antioxidant when
studied in the test tube. However there have been limited animal
studies and no human studies of this compound. There is no proof
as to benefits of this compound compared to the antioxidant effects
of Vitamins C or E.
QUININE
This medication
is used by cyclists as a cure for leg cramps. However it can cause
a drop in blood count and has been linked to 16 deaths, so the
FDA in America has banned it. Cramping cyclists should fight leg
cramps with proper hydration, training, and electrolyte replacement
instead.
SELENIUM
Thought to have a possible role as an antioxidant, there is little
evidence this mineral plays a significant role in minimizing the
harmful effects of free radicals. It almost certainly plays a
less significant role than Vit C or Vit E, and the occurrence
of specific selenium deficiency in humans is quite rare. It is
found naturally in seafood, meats, and grains, and specific supplementation
is not recommended.
SIBERIAN GINSENG
A chinese herb, questionably related to ginseng - as in many of
these herbal products it is difficult to determine the exact chemical
makeup - claimed to have benefit as a brain stimulant. A group
of volunteers is reported to have shown an increase in mental
alertness and work output, while another study suggested an increase
in athletic performance under stressful conditions such as heat
and noise. As with other herbal products, these claims are anecdotal
and there is no scientific proof of increased athletic performance.
SMILAX (smilax
officinalis)
Smilax Officinalis, native to the tropics of Brazil, began as
a pharmaceutical base for the production of certain anabolic steroids.
However, without the chemical modifications, smilax officinalis
is thought to be non-toxic and its use has no known negative side
effects. It is alleged to raise the blood content of testosterone
- the male growth hormone - and to be equivalent to anabolic steroids
in gains of lean muscle mass and defined tissue. However these
performance claims are not supported by published research studies.
SODIUM BICARBONATE
(baking soda) (++)
A chemical compound available as baking soda or Alka Seltzer,
sodium bicarbonate buffers lactic acid allowing longer bouts of
near maximal cycling for short, high intensity sprint events lasting
1 to 7 minutes (400m. or 800m. sprints, time trials), but of minimal
additional effect compared to the body's natural buffering capacity
for lactic acid during very short intense exercise lasting less
than 30 seconds or sustained endurance events. Generally, studies
that used doses of 300 mg/kg body wt. found an ergogenic effect,
while those using less than 200 mg/kg showed no effect.
Sodium bicarbonate should be considered of probable benefit
in very specific circumstances but has certain drawbacks that
may outweigh these advantages.
SODIUM CHLORIDE
Over a 24-hour
period, the athlete's standard training diet will replace two
to three times the normal salt losses. Only under extreme environmental
conditions of high temperature or high humidity is a salt supplement
needed. An exception might be the cyclist who has not trained
for an event and can lose excessive amounts of salt in his/her
perspiration. Although exercise cramps were once thought to be
the result of salt deficiency, it now appears that they are related
to dehydration and a decreased blood flow to the muscles.
VITAMIN B12
No studies have documented enhanced lean muscle mass or strength.
It is non-toxic even at high doses.
YOHIMBINE
An
alkaloid extracted from the bark of the yohimbe tree and claimed
to have an anabolic effect through stimulating the release of
testosterone or human growth hormone. Performance claims are not
supported by published research studies.
|